Buying a home and renting one are hard to compare on monthly cost alone. This calculator follows two otherwise identical households, one that buys and one that rents, and shows which ends up with more net worth after the years you expect to stay.
It is for anyone deciding whether to buy now or keep renting, and for testing how sensitive that answer is to rates, price growth and time. It works in any currency; the currency picker changes the symbol only.
01How it works
Both households start with the same cash. The buyer spends it on the down payment and buying costs. The renter invests the same amount at the return you enter.
The model then runs month by month. The buyer pays the mortgage (monthly rate = yearly rate ÷ 12), property tax and maintenance as a yearly percentage of the home's current value, and insurance as a fixed yearly amount. The renter pays rent, which rises once a year by the rent increase you set. Whoever has the lower housing cost that month invests the difference, and both investment pots grow at the same return, compounded monthly.
The home value grows each month at the yearly price growth rate. At the end, the buyer is assumed to sell: net worth is the home value minus selling costs and the remaining loan, plus anything the buyer invested. The renter's net worth is their investment pot. The first year in which buying comes out ahead is shown as the break-even year.
Left out: taxes on investment gains or home sales, mortgage-interest relief, rises in insurance costs, and mortgage insurance. These vary by country and can change the result.
Upfront cash = down payment + price × buying costs % Owner cost / month = mortgage payment + value × (tax % + maintenance %) / 12 + insurance / 12 Each month: both pots × (1 + g); lower-cost side invests (higher cost − lower cost) g = (1 + return %)^(1/12) − 1 Buy net worth = value × (1 − selling costs %) − loan balance + buyer pot Rent net worth = renter pot
02Worked example
A 400,000 home, 20% down, a 6.5% mortgage over 30 years, 3% buying costs and 6% selling costs. Property tax and maintenance are 1% of value a year each, insurance 1,500 a year. A similar home rents for 2,000 a month, rising 3% a year. Home prices grow 3% a year and invested savings earn 6%. You plan to stay 7 years.
- Cash needed to buy: 80,000 + 12,000 = 92,000. The renter invests this instead.
- Mortgage payment: 2,022.62. In month one the owner pays 2,814.28 in total against 2,000 in rent, so the renter invests the 814.28 difference.
- After 7 years, net worth if you buy: 173,100.59. Net worth if you rent and invest: 211,579.77.
- Renting leaves you ahead by 38,479.18, and buying does not pull ahead within the 7 years.
Over 7 years the buyer pays 334,537.95 in housing costs (including the upfront cash) against 183,899.09 in rent. With the same inputs, buying is still behind after 20 years (505,089.57 against 510,638.09), so the outcome here depends heavily on the rate, rent and growth assumptions.
03Questions
Why does the renter invest money?
To compare fairly, both sides spend the same total. Cash the buyer puts into the home, and any month where renting is cheaper, is invested by the renter. When owning becomes cheaper than rent, the buyer invests the difference instead.
What does break-even year mean?
It is the first full year in which the buyer's net worth, after selling costs and paying off the loan, is at least the renter's. If it never happens within your time frame, the page says so.
Why do selling costs matter so much?
The model assumes you sell at the end. Selling costs come straight off the home value, so over a short stay they can outweigh the equity built up.
Are taxes included?
No. Tax on investment returns, tax on home sales and any relief on mortgage interest differ by country and are left out. They can tilt the result either way.
Which inputs matter most?
Usually the time you stay, the gap between home price growth and the investment return, the mortgage rate, and rent compared with the price. Try changing one at a time to see how sensitive the answer is.